If the holiday season has you scrambling for dessert options, look no further than Costco's bakery section, where seasonal treats abound. Whether you're hosting a festive gathering or need to bring a dessert to a holiday party, Costco offers a convenient solution to satisfy all your sweet cravings. We've taste-tested 10 of Costco's top bakery items to help you decide which treats deserve a spot on your holiday table.

The Sweetest Disappointments

Not every dessert is a winner, and our taste test revealed a few that you might want to skip. The Caramel Tres Leches Bar Cake, with its wet, spongy texture and unappealing sheen, failed to impress. Similarly, the Kirkland Signature White Chocolate Raspberry Round Cake disappointed with its synthetic raspberry scent and sponge-like consistency. The Kirkland Signature Raspberry Morning Buns were overly tart and stale, making them a hard pass.

Unexpected Surprises

Some of Costco's offerings pleasantly surprised us. The Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake exceeded expectations with its delightful crunch and pleasant maple aroma, despite its bland appearance. The Chocolate Orange Loaf, skeptical at first, proved to be a unique combination, although it fell short with its dense texture and lack of chocolate chunks.

Seasonal Favorites

Among the tested treats, a few stood out as must-haves for the holiday season. The Cinnamon Rolls, despite being a bit stale, offer a convenient alternative to homemade, with a tangy icing twist. The Holiday Cookie Tray shines as a party favorite, offering a variety of cookies to please any crowd, despite some being less flavorful than others.

The Cream of the Crop

Leading the pack, the Cherry Topped Cheesecake dazzled with its classic dense flavor and sweet cherries, though the crust left something to be desired. The Kirkland Signature Tuxedo Chocolate Mousse Cake was a chocolate lover's dream, rich and satisfying with its diverse layers and festive decoration. Lastly, the White Mini Cakes with White Buttercream Icing stole the show as a crowd-pleaser, combining moist cake with sweet icing and adorable Christmas decorations.

Conclusion: Look for the Mistletoe

When navigating Costco's bakery this holiday season, keep an eye out for treats adorned with mistletoe decorations - they're likely to be the best bets for satisfying your sweet tooth. Whether you're in need of a last-minute dessert or looking to indulge in seasonal flavors, Costco's bakery section has something for everyone.