There's nothing more classic and comforting in American cuisine than a golden, buttery grilled cheese sandwich. It's a staple that evokes nostalgia and culinary creativity alike. But with so many variations and interpretations available, especially from popular restaurant chains, which one truly stands above the rest? I embarked on a journey through New Mexico and Oklahoma, sampling the grilled cheese offerings from five different chains to find out.

Schlotzky's: A Sourdough Misstep

My first stop was Schlotzky's, a chain known for its fluffy sourdough buns. Unfortunately, their grilled cheese, featuring mozzarella and cheddar on a sesame-seeded sourdough bun, fell flat. The sandwich was overly bready, lacked sufficient cheese, and the bread's texture was disappointingly rubbery and greasy. Priced at $8.79, it was a letdown that didn't live up to the grilled cheese dream.

Tom & Chee: High Hopes, Mediocre Reality

Next up was Tom & Chee, a chain that prides itself on "gourmet" grilled cheese variations. Expectations were high, but the reality was a basic, somewhat greasy sandwich that didn't deliver on the promise of a grilled cheese specialty shop. The American and cheddar on white bread combo was underwhelming, lacking in cheese and warmth. At $5.49, it was fine but forgettable. Their grilled cheese donut, an adventurous attempt, ended up being a confusing mix of flavors that didn't quite mesh.

Sonic: Classic Comfort at a Comforting Price

Sonic, the epitome of American fast food, offered up a no-frills grilled cheese that hit the spot. Using Texas toast and American cheese, this sandwich brought back memories of childhood simplicity. Priced at only $2.59, it was a small, nostalgic, and satisfying option that proved sometimes simpler is better, despite its slightly too sweet bread.

Panera Bread: Almost Perfect

With high expectations, Panera Bread mostly delivered with its classic grilled cheese. The combination of American cheese on white miche, especially when paired with their creamy tomato soup, was a delightful experience. The sandwich, costing $10.18 with soup, had a great cheese-to-bread ratio, though the bread could have been toastier. Nevertheless, it was a strong contender in the grilled cheese game.

Five Guys: The Unexpected Champion

The biggest surprise came from Five Guys, a place better known for its burgers and fries. Their unique take on grilled cheese, using an inside-out sesame seed bun and plenty of American cheese, was nothing short of genius. Priced at $6.29, it offered the perfect balance of buttery, toasty goodness without being overly greasy or heavy. This inventive and delicious sandwich stole the show, making Five Guys my top pick for a grilled cheese craving.

In the quest for the ultimate grilled cheese, it's clear that simplicity often reigns supreme, but a little creativity can go a long way. From the disappointing to the delightful, this cross-country taste test revealed that when it comes to grilled cheese, there's a wide range of interpretations, but only a few can truly capture the essence of this beloved American classic.

*** We appreciate our sponsor ***

Image Credit: Virgil Malone / AuthorsUSA.com